After months of rumors, the cast of Love Island All-Stars Season 2 is finally confirmed! In Love Island UK’s first All-Stars season, Molly Smith and Tom Clare won the 50k pound prize. This year, the cast includes some fan favorites, a few notorious villains, and a former couple who had a very messy breakup. Here’s everything you need to know about the returning Islanders of All-Stars Season 2.
Scott Thomas, Season 2
2025’s Love Island All-Stars cast kicks off with a true OG from way back in Season 2! During his initial run, Scott Thomas was paired with Kady McDermott, who re-appeared on Season 10. Season 2 was way back in 2016, and Scott is 36 years old now, so we’ll have to see if wisdom really does come with age for our Islanders.
Marcel Sommerville, Season 3
Season 3 is my favorite, so I’m thrilled to have two Islanders confirmed so far. And these are messy picks, for reasons we’ll get to.
Before Love Island, Marcel Sommerville was a member of the boy band Blazin’ Squad. Marcel initially acted like he wanted to keep this under wraps, but he definitely didn’t. It launched one of the best recurring gags/drinking games in Love Island history – take a shot every time Marcel finds an excuse to bring up Blazin’ Squad.
As the oldest contestant, he also took on a mentor role. I can still hear narrator Iain Stirling saying, “Paging Dr. Marcel!!!” every time another Islander had a crisis. On All-Stars Season 2, he’s once again the oldest, at 39-years-old. Marcel remained friends with quite a few of his Season 3 co-stars, including Olivia Atwood. He was also at Camilla Thurlow and Jamie Jewitt’s wedding.
Speaking of weddings, Marcel returns to the villa as a recent divorcee. He split from Rebecca Vieira, with whom he shares a son, last year. Rebecca allegedly cheated on him with rapper Slim Jxmmi. It’s not Marcel’s first cheating scandal.
Gabby Allen, Season 3
Speaking of Marcel, his ex Gabby Allen will also return. Marcel and Gabby were a fan-favorite couple in Season 3 and landed in fourth place. After the season wrapped, they dated for nearly a year. Then, Gabby found out Marcel cheated on her while they were on holiday. It was all very messy. Years later, have old wounds healed?
Since her time on Love Island, Gabby has worked as a fitness influencer. She also appeared on Ex on the Beach.
Kaz Crossley, Season 4
Kaz was a finalist in Season 4, winning third place with Josh Denzel. They broke up six months later. Kaz went on to date Season 3 star Theo Campbell for about a year. She later appeared on Celebrity Ex on the Beach and The Challenge UK. Kaz returns to the villa nearly two years after she made headlines for being in-prisoned in Dubai. She recently opened up about this ordeal on GK Barry’s podcast.
Curtis Pritchard, Season 5
Up next is Curtis Pritchard, aka Maura Higgins’ ex. He previously appeared on Season 1 of Love Island Games, where he had an awkward reunion with Maura. On that season, he failed to win Justine Ndiba’s heart. Maybe the third time will be the charm?
Curtis is a very polarizing Love Island star, but he gave us some of the most iconic moments, for better or worse. He and Amy Hart were the Barbie and Ken of the villa until Casa Amor. Curtis blew it up, and all for a bombshell who chose another contestant instead. The devastated Amy gave us an all-timer by yelling, “I was coming back here to tell you that I loved you!” When she confronted him about not cuddling her in the morning, Curtis said it was more important to him to make coffee for the rest of the villa. Maura then shocked everyone by declaring feelings for Curtis out of nowhere. They came in fourth place, but Curtis allegedly cheated on her in the outside world.
Elma Pazar, Season 5
Elma was right by Maura’s side when they made their iconic bombshell entrance. Elma instantly caught the eye of Anton Danyluk, who competed in All-Stars Season 1. She also competed with Maura for Tom Walker, before getting eliminated after two weeks. In addition to LI UK, Elma also appeared on TOWIE.
India Reynolds, Season 5
Gorgeous model India Reynolds was one of Season 5’s final bombshells. She came in third place when coupled with Ovie Soko. Ovie is definitely a dream All-Stars cast member for many fans, so we’ll see if he shows up this year. It’s probably a long shot, however.
India was (unwittingly) responsible for one of the most dramatic Love Island blowups ever. Two days (“TWO DAYS!!”) after asking Anna Valki to be his girlfriend, Jordan Hames pulled India for a chat. Never mind that India was happy with Ovie. Curtis encouraged Jordan, much to Maura’s chagrin. Maura told Anna, and the villa absolutely erupted. Maybe India will inspire some similarly chaotic moments on All-Stars?
Nas Majeed, Season 6
On the show’s first winter season, Nas was the sweetheart short king who, inexplicably, none of the girls would go for. That was until Demi. But the two were only coupled for a few days before the infamous Casa Amor challenge. Nas shocked Demi, and the viewers, by recoupling with Eva. But they proved naysayers wrong and stayed together for four years. Now single again, Nas is returning to South Africa, and hopefully won’t have to wait as long to find some matches.
Luca Bish, Season 8
Introducing himself as “My name is Luca Bish and I sell fish,” the fishmonger was one of Season 8’s more notorious villains. Particularly cruel was his taunting of the show’s first deaf contestant, Tasha Ghouri. It got so bad that thousands of Ofcom complaints were filed about his behavior, and he had to apologize to Tasha on the show. His own parents confronted Luca about this on Parents’ Day. These days, Tasha and Luca appear to be on decent terms, but it left a bad taste in viewers’ mouths.
Additionally, Luca was accused of acting possessive of then-girlfriend Gemma Owen. The couple had plenty of fans and were runners-up, but some posted memes comparing him to Joe from the show You. They split two months after the finale. Gemma was rumored to be on All-Stars Season 2, so we may have another ex-reunion on our hands.
Olivia Hawkins, Season 9
Speaking of Love Island villains, Olivia “Liv” Hawkins took that role in Season 9. A friend of mine even compared the actress’ cadence to Severus Snape from Harry Potter. Michelle Keegan’s former stand-in really got under viewers’ skin when she tried to come for Kai Fagan because he recoupled with Sanam Harrinanan in Casa Amor. Despite recoupling herself! Kai and Sanam won, and are now engaged. Will Olivia find lasting love herself this time?
Catherine Agbaje, Season 10
Catherine started out strong on Season 10, but viewers turned on her after she recoupled in Casa Amor. While some fans hoped the Irish beauty would reunite with Scott Vandersloot in the outside world, he went on to appear on Love Island USA and Love Island Games back-to-back. Now, Catherine is following in her former paramour’s footsteps by returning to another villa.
Ronnie Vint, Season 11
If you skipped last summer’s LI UK, you’re not alone. Lots of viewers grew frustrated as it became the Joey Essex show. Plus, LI USA had its greatest season yet, so viewers on both sides of the pond changed the channel.
Those who stuck with the UK watched as every girl went gaga for Ronnie Vint. It was mostly surprising because he’s far from the usual type that girls fight over every season. But Islanders cried over him from day 2, he made out with breakout Uma before the show and kept up a never-ending love triangle with two women no matter how much he mugged them off. Sadly, he was eliminated before we could see what kind of havoc he’d cause in Casa Amor.
Who else may appear on All-Stars Season 2?
Love Island mixes things up by periodically adding bombshells. So, if your favorite isn’t on this list, that doesn’t mean they won’t appear. A popular rumor is that Ekin-Su Cülcüloğlu will be the first bombshell of All-Stars Season 2. That would be huge, especially because Ekin is widely held as the greatest bombshell ever, next to Maura and Ovie. Others rumored to appear include Gemma Owen, Paige Thorne, and Sammy Root.
Love Island All-Stars can be streamed on Peacock.
TELL US – WHAT DO YOU THINK OF THE LOVE ISLAND ALL-STARS SEASON 2 CAST? WHO ARE YOU THE MOST EXCITED TO SEE BACK? WHO DO YOU HOPE RETURNS AS A BOMBSHELL?